Aired 5/8/13
The Idols will be doing three songs (swongs, as Nicki would say) tonight, none of their own choosing. That is a good and a bad thing. Historically, one of the bad things has been that the apparently amnesiac judges usually can't manage to prevent themselves from critiquing song choice. Also bad because the powers that be don't always pick good songs. The good thing is...wait, is there a good thing?
Like us and share on Facebook!
AMERICAN IDOL TOP 3
THEMES:
1) Jimmy Iovine's choice
2) Judges' choice
3) Idol production picks

As a reminder, here's how the Prognosticats rate the contestants every week:
RATING SYSTEM
Litterbox Level
Paws-itively Purr-fect
Jimmy Iovine's choice
Kree Harrison

Perfect
by Pink
Zinni 
Zoey 
Candice Glover

One
by U2
Zinni 
Zoey 
Angie Miller

Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word
by Elton John
Zinni 
Zoey 
JUDGES' CHOICE
Candice Glover

Next to Me
by Emile Sandi
Zinni 
Zoey 
Angie Miller

Try
by Pink
Zinni 
Zoey 
Kree Harrison

Here Comes Goodbye
by Rascal Flatts
Zinni 
Zoey 
IDOL PRODUCTION CHOICE
Angie Miller

Maybe
by Emeli Sande
Zinni 
Zoey 
Kree Harrison

Better Dig Two
by The Band Perry
Zinni 
Zoey 
Candice Glover

Somewhere
from West Side Story
Zinni 
Zoey 
Download music from your favorite past Idols at iTunes!


CATTICISMS
Zinni:
• Kree got a good look at the underside of the bus tonight. Perfect and Better Dig Two, while Candice gets Somewhere and One? Really? Don't get me wrong, I love Candice, but Kree's getting the short end of the stick here.
• Angie never got a two-singer break between songs! What's up with that?
Zoey:
• Too many tears tonight. Just kind of a weird night.
• Shut UP already, Randy, with the "in it to win it" thing. SHUT IT!
Download the American Idol app from the App Store (click on the button below):

Join us tomorrow night to find out who gets "scratched"!