Tonight we find out who will be in the finale. Here are the Prognosticats' picks for who's going home instead:

PREDICTIONS

Zinni
Should go home: Phillip Phillips
Will go home: Phillip Phillips

Zoey

Should go home: Phillip Phillips
Will go home: Jessica Sanchez

Who will be in the top 3 on American Idol's eleventh season? Here are the Prognosticats' picks:

PREDICTIONS

Zinni
Should go home: Phillip Phillips
Will go home: Hollie Cavanagh

Zoey

Should go home: Phillip Phillips
Will go home: Hollie Cavanagh

Once again, it could be anyone going home tonight on American Idol, but let's see what the Prognosticats have to say:

PREDICTIONS

Zinni
Should go home: Phillip Phillips
Will go home: Hollie Cavanagh

Zoey

Should go home: Phillip Phillips
Will go home: Skylar Laine

The field seemed pretty even last night, so who knows what'll happen tonight on American Idol? Here are the Prognosticats' picks:

PREDICTIONS

Zinni
Bottom 3: Hollie, Elise, Jessica
Should go home: Phillip Phillips
Will go home: Elise Testone

Zoey
Bottom 3: Elise, Jessica, Skylar
Should go home: Phillip Phillips
Will go home: Phillip Phillips

Based on last week's surprise almost-elimination on American Idol, it's clear that anyone could go home tonight. But here's what the Prognosticats are thinking:

PREDICTIONS

Zinni
Bottom 3: Hollie, Elise, Jessica
Should go home: Joshua Ledet
Will go home: Hollie Cavanagh

Zoey
Bottom 3: Elise, Phillip, Joshua
Should go home: Phillip Phillips
Will go home: Elise Testone

Pretty good night last night on American Idol, with many contestants earning three or more paws from the Prognosticats. Here are their guesses for tonight's possible elimination.

PREDICTIONS

Zinni
Bottom 3: Elise, Skylar, Hollie
Should go home: Joshua Ledet
Will go home: Hollie Cavanagh
Judges' save: No

Zoey
Bottom 3: Hollie, Elise, Phillip
Should go home: Phillip Phillips
Will go home: Hollie Cavanagh
Judges' save: Yes

At this point, we think that the judges would definitely save Joshua, Jessica, Phillip, and Colton, and maybe save Elise, Hollie, and Skylar.

Most of the performances on American Idol last night seemed to be in the middle of the road, at least to the Prognosticats' way of thinking. Here's who they think is going home:

PREDICTIONS

Zinni
Should go home: DeAndre Brackensick
Will go home: Hollie Cavanagh
Judges' save: No

Zoey
Should go home: DeAndre Brackensick
Will go home: Elise Testone
Judges' save: No

Interesting night last night. Tough to tell who'll be going home, but here's what the Prognosticats think:

PREDICTIONS

Zinni
Elimination prediction: DeAndre Brackensick
I think America has had enough falsetto.

Zoey
Elimination prediction: Heejun Han
He straightened up last night but it may be too little too late.

So who goes and who stays? Here's what our favorite felines think:

PREDICTIONS

Zinni
Elimination prediction: Heejun Han
He doesn't seem to take this seriously; time for him to go.

Zoey
Elimination prediction: Erika Van Pelt
The new hair may not be enough to save her.

Tonight's results are kind of unpredictable; there could be some unexpected method of dealing with the Jermaine Jones situation. The schedule for the season is likely set up far in advance, and having one too few contestants would put a monkey wrench into that. Will they spring a non-elimination show on us in the final seconds? Tune in to find out!

However, if they do indeed eliminate someone, here are the Prognosticats' picks:

PREDICTIONS

Zinni
Elimination prediction: Elise Testone

Zoey
Elimination prediction: Elise Testone