Idol season 9 top 5: Silence the lambs

by bunny on May 4, 2010

Aired 5/4/10

Tonight we'll be hearing Frank Sinatra songs, with mentoring and arrangements by Harry Connick, Jr.

RATING SYSTEM


Litterbox Level


Paws-itively Purr-fect

Aaron Kelly

Aaron Kelly
Fly Me to the Moon

Odyssey Aaron Ross Space Bar Matt Kelly Green Limited Edition BMX Bike Handlebar Odyssey Aaron Ross Space Bar Matt Kelly Green Limited Edition BMX Bike Handlebar Paypal US $64.95 3h 52m
Powered by phpBay Pro

Casey James

Casey James
Blue Skies

Crystal Bowersox

Crystal Bowersox
Summer Wind

BOWERSOXCRYSTAL FARMERS DAUGHTER CD NEW] BOWERSOXCRYSTAL FARMERS DAUGHTER CD NEW] Paypal US $12.41 19d 21h 10m
Powered by phpBay Pro

Michael Lynche

Michael Lynche
The Way You Look Tonight

MICHAEL LYNCHE UNSIGNED AMERICAN IDOL 8X10 PHOTO MICHAEL LYNCHE UNSIGNED AMERICAN IDOL 8X10 PHOTO Paypal US $4.75 21d 7h 9m
Powered by phpBay Pro

Lee Dewyze

Lee Dewyze
That's Life

Lee DeWyze So Im Told cd SEALED Lee DeWyze So Im Told cd SEALED Paypal US $6.99 23d 15h 57m
Powered by phpBay Pro

JUDGING THE JUDGES

They’re being evaluated on the basis of their constructive criticism, coherence, and entertainment value.

Randy

Ellen

Kara

Simon

CATTICISMS

Zinni: Crystal better stop defending herself after minor criticism or she's going to start ticking people off. We cats don't care, but humans do.

See you tomorrow for the results!

{ 2 comments }

Wedding DJs May 5, 2010 at 8:11 am

Casey was awful, but we still think Aaron sucked eggs.

Crystal was OK, and same with Big Mike.

But the big surprise was Lee, he really nailed “That’s Life” and his voice was spot on.

Right now, it looks like Lee DeWyze is the only one of the guys who can beat “Pigpen Smellysox”.

PinkRibbonChic May 5, 2010 at 1:17 pm

I agree with Zinni people get tired of that fast and she has been doing it the last few performances now. May just get her in the bottom 3 tonight. I dont think Casey was awful. He just looked and felt awkward without his guitar. I agree with u Wedding DJs on ur comment about Lee. I normally prefer his studios over his live but he really brought it last night. Im hoping that Big Mike leaves us tonight.

Previous post:

Next post: