ELIMINATED
Jacob Lusk
RESULTS
Zinni's Prediction vs. Actual Outcome
Jacob Lusk - Jacob Lusk
Zoey's Prediction vs. Actual Outcome
Jacob Lusk - Jacob Lusk
SCORES (Running Totals)
Zinni: 13 out of 20
Zoey: 13 out of 20
Who will make it to the top 4? Here's what the Prognosticats say:
PREDICTIONS
Zinni
Should go home: Jacob Lusk
Will go home: Jacob Lusk
Zoey
Should go home: Jacob Lusk
Will go home: Jacob Lusk
Aired 5/4/11
Tonight, the American Idol top 5 will sing two songs: One from now and one from "back in the day," presumably in the '60s. Sheryl Crow is mentoring.
Only Zoey will be rating the contestants tonight, but both Prognosticats will make their picks before tomorrow's results.
RATING SYSTEM
Litterbox Level
Paws-itively Purr-fect
NOW
James Durbin
Closer to the Edge by 30 Seconds to Mars
Zoey 
Jacob Lusk
No Air by Jordin Sparks
Zoey 
Lauren Alaina
Flat On the Floor by Carrie Underwood
Zoey 
Scotty McCreery
Gone by Montgomery Gentry
Zoey 
Haley Reinhart
You and I by Lady Gaga
Zoey 
THEN
James Durbin
Without You by Harry Nilsson
Zoey
Jacob Lusk
Love Hurts by Nazareth
Zoey
Lauren Alaina
Unchained Melody by the Righteous Brothers
Zoey
Scotty McCreery
Always On My Mind by Elvis Presley
Zoey
Haley Reinhart
House of the Rising Sun by the Animals
Zoey
Get the iPhone app American Idol: The Game
JUDGING THE JUDGES
Steven
Jennifer
Randy
Download your favorite music on iTunes
CATTICISMS
Zinni: It's like the judges don't even care whether the idols sing well anymore. Or did they ever? Not this season, that's for sure. On the plus side, Scotty held the microphone fairly straight tonight.
Zoey: Randy is going to drive me up the wall. What channel is The Voice on again? Meow.
Seacrest out!
ELIMINATED
Casey Abrams
RESULTS
Zinni's Prediction vs. Actual Outcome
Haley Reinhart - Casey Abrams
Zoey's Prediction vs. Actual Outcome
Jacob Lusk - Casey Abrams
SCORES (Running Totals)
Zinni: 12 out of 19
Zoey: 12 out of 19
Who have the chops to be in the top 5? Here's what the Prognosticats say:
PREDICTIONS
Zinni
Should go home: Jacob Lusk
Will go home: Haley Reinhart
Zoey
Should go home: Jacob Lusk
Will go home: Jacob Lusk
Aired 4/27/11
We apologize for the delay in posting the Prognosticats' review of Carole King night on American Idol; we were without Internet service for the last 24 hours. But we're back at it!
RATING SYSTEM
Litterbox Level
Paws-itively Purr-fect
Jacob Lusk
Oh No Not My Baby
Zinni
Zoey
Lauren Alaina
Where You Lead
Zinni
Zoey
Scotty McCreery
You've Got A Friend
Zinni
Zoey
James Durbin
Will You Love Me Tomorrow
Zinni
Zoey
Casey Abrams
Hi-De-Ho
Zinni
Zoey
Haley Reinhart
Beautiful
Zinni
Zoey
Get the iPhone app American Idol: The Game
JUDGING THE JUDGES
Steven
Jennifer
Randy
Download your favorite music on iTunes
CATTICISMS
Zoey: Randy's "critiques" are more about getting applause for himself from the audience than about the actual singer's skill or lack thereof.
Seacrest out!
ELIMINATED
Stefano Langone
RESULTS
Zinni's Prediction vs. Actual Outcome
Stefano Langone - Stefano Langone
Zoey's Prediction vs. Actual Outcome
Casey Abrams - Stefano Langone
SCORES (Running Totals)
Zinni: 12 out of 18
Zoey: 12 out of 18
CATTICISMS
Zoey: Katy Perry—give me a break. Meow.
Who will make it into the top 6? Here's what the Prognosticats say:
PREDICTIONS
Zinni
Should go home: Jacob Lusk
Will go home: Stefano Langone
Zoey
Should go home: Jacob Lusk
Will go home: Casey Abrams
Aired 4/20/11
Your American Idol top 7 are doing songs from the 21st century tonight. Could be very bad or could be very good. Their song choices will reveal something about how they view themselves and their possible niche in the music scene.
RATING SYSTEM
Litterbox Level
Paws-itively Purr-fect
Scotty McCreery
Swingin' by Leann Rimes (and John Anderson)
Zinni
Zoey
James Durbin
Uprising by Muse
Zinni
Zoey
Haley Reinhart
Rolling In the Deep by Adele
Zinni
Zoey
Jacob Lusk
Dance With My Father by Luther Vandross
Zinni
Zoey
Casey Abrams
Harder To Breathe by Maroon 5
Zinni
Zoey
Stefano Langone
Closer by Ne-Yo
Zinni
Zoey
Lauren Alaina
Born To Fly by Sara Evans
Zinni
Zoey
Get the iPhone app American Idol: The Game
JUDGING THE JUDGES
Steven
Jennifer
Randy
Download your favorite music on iTunes
CATTICISMS
Zinni: Can Steven not speak without using non-family-friendly language?
Zoey: And doesn't he have his own microphone?
Seacrest out!
ELIMINATED
RESULTS
Zinni's Prediction vs. Actual Outcome
Haley Reinhart - Paul McDonald
Zoey's Prediction vs. Actual Outcome
Paul McDonald - Paul McDonald
SCORES (Running Totals)
Zinni: 11 out of 17
Zoey: 12 out of 17
CATTICISMS
Zoey: Everything is as it should be. Including the fact that I am now ahead of Big Z. Meow.
