Aired 5/11/11
Tonight, your top 4 on American Idol will sing one song that inspires them personally and one from the Lieber and Stoller songbook. Lady Gaga is mentoring.
RATING SYSTEM
Litterbox Level
Paws-itively Purr-fect
James Durbin
Don't Stop Believing by Journey
Zinni 
Zoey
Love Potion #9 by the Clovers
Zinni 
Zoey 
Haley Reinhart
Earth Song by Michael Jackson
Zinni
Zoey
I Who Have Nothing by Tom Jones
Zinni 
Zoey
Scotty McCreery
Where Were You (When the World Stopped Turning) by Alan Jackson
Zinni
Zoey
Young Blood by the Coasters
Zinni
Zoey
Lauren Alaina
Anyway by Martina McBride
Zinni
Zoey
Trouble by Elvis
Zinni
Zoey
Get the iPhone app American Idol: The Game
JUDGING THE JUDGES
Steven
Jennifer
Randy
Download your favorite music on iTunes
CATTICISMS
Zinni: Haley, honey, you don't need to growl and/or yodel in every song. And Lady Gaga is just cuckoo, plain and simple.
Zoey: I like Scotty much better when he's not touching the mic. On another subject, if Simon were still here, he'd be calling most of James' performances self-indulgent.
Seacrest out!
