Season 12 top 4: Then and now, the melody is enough

by bunny on May 1, 2013

Aired 5/1/13

Harry Connick, Jr. is mentoring the Idols tonight as they sing songs from 2013 and then the old standards. Like the songs that Randy grew up on...

Like us and share on Facebook!

AMERICAN IDOL TOP 4
THEMES:
1) Songs from 2013
2) Standards/classics

idol12top4

As a reminder, here's how the Prognosticats rate the contestants every week:

RATING SYSTEM


Litterbox Level


Paws-itively Purr-fect

Songs from 2013

Angie Miller

Angie Miller
Diamonds
by Rihanna
Zinni
Zoey 

Amber Holcomb

Amber Holcomb
Just Give Me a Reason
by Pink
Zinni
Zoey 

Candice Glover

Candice Glover
When I Was Your Man
by Bruno Mars
Zinni
Zoey 

Kree Harrison

Kree Harrison
See You Again
by Carrie Underwood
Zinni
Zoey 

STANDARDS

Angie Miller

Angie Miller
Someone To Watch Over Me
Zinni
Zoey 

Amber Holcomb

Amber Holcomb
My Funny Valentine
Zinni
Zoey 

Candice Glover

Candice Glover
You've Changed
Zinni
Zoey 

Kree Harrison

Kree Harrison
Stormy Weather
Zinni
Zoey 

Download music from your favorite past Idols at iTunes!

US iTunes, App Store, iBookstore, and Mac App Store

 

CATTICISMS

Zinni:
• Some good advice from Harry about thinking about the lyrics and not just figuring out where to put runs. The Idols have heard that a lot this year, more than I ever remember, and there are a lot of other young wannabe stars who would also do well to heed that advice. The melody is enough.
• I wouldn't be unhappy to see any one of these four ladies win; they're all great. And quite sparkly.

Zoey:
• Maybe if Nicki weren't so long-winded, we could get this thing done in an hour instead of two.
• I wouldn't mind seeing Keith and Mariah again next year. Time for Randy to go, and take that other thing with you.
• Tonight's debate between Randy and Harry—we have to go with Harry, of course. He's a singer. Randy's a...what is Randy again?

Download the American Idol app from the App Store (click on the button below):

American Idol - FOX Broadcasting Company

Join us tomorrow night to find out who gets "scratched"!

Previous post:

Next post: